Talk to an Advisor

Tax Straddling Strategy

In the latter part of the year, engaging in a 1031 Exchange can offer a unique opportunity known as tax straddling. This method becomes relevant when the exchange is either successful or unsuccessful. Successful completion allows taxpayers to defer taxes and reap the benefits of the 1031 Exchange. If the exchange is not completed, however, taxpayers face imminent tax obligations. Nonetheless, there’s a silver lining: they may qualify for a “mini-tax deferral. This means they can delay reporting and paying their taxes until their 2024 tax returns, instead of on their 2023 returns.

Here’s a detailed look at how tax straddling functions. Suppose a taxpayer initiates a 1031 Exchange towards the end of 2023 (after October 17th), but it fails. The tax on the gains from the sale becomes due. If the intermediary handling the 1031 Exchange doesn’t return the funds until after December 31st, the process extends into 2024, creating an Installment Sale under IRC Section 453 and related 1031 regulations.

With tax straddling, particularly when dealing with an unsuccessful 1031 Exchange, taxpayers are presented with two distinct choices. Each choice has its implications and requirements, and understanding these options is crucial for making an informed decision.

Choice 1: Immediate Reporting in the Year of Sale

  • What it Involves: This option requires the taxpayer to report the taxable gain in the tax return for the year in which the property was originally sold. In the context of a 1031 Exchange initiated late in the year, this would typically mean reporting the gain in the same year the exchange was started and subsequently failed.
  • Regulatory Reference: Detailed rules and guidelines for this election can be found in IRS Publication 537.
  • Implications: Choosing this option means the taxpayer accepts the tax liability in the same fiscal year as the sale of the property. There’s no deferral of tax payment in this scenario. It’s a straightforward approach, where the taxpayer settles the tax obligations without delay.

Choice 2: Deferred Reporting in the Year of Receiving Sale Proceeds

  • What it Entails: Under this choice, the taxpayer defers reporting the taxable gain until the tax return for the following year. This is contingent on the taxpayer receiving the sale proceeds in the next year, which is a common occurrence when the exchange process extends beyond December 31st.
  • Legal Basis: The option is grounded in the Installment Sale provisions under IRC Section 453.
  • Benefits: The primary advantage here is the deferral of tax liability. By pushing the tax obligation to the next fiscal year, the taxpayer effectively gains a one-year window to manage or offset the tax impact. This can be particularly advantageous from a financial planning perspective, as it provides additional time to arrange finances or explore other tax-saving measures.
  • Considerations: It’s important for the taxpayer to understand that while this choice offers a temporary reprieve from immediate tax payments, it doesn’t eliminate the tax liability. The deferred taxes will still need to be addressed in the subsequent tax year.

Each of these choices has its own set of benefits and considerations. The immediate reporting option is more straightforward and clears tax liabilities without delay, while the deferred reporting offers temporary relief, giving taxpayers additional time to manage their finances. Taxpayers should consider their overall financial situation, cash flow requirements, and potential tax planning strategies for the following year before making a decision.

Opting for the second choice allows for a one-year deferral on the gains. Tax straddling is an attractive option for investors selling property at year’s end, as there’s no IRS penalty for attempting a 1031 Exchange. It serves as a viable backup plan for a one-year deferral.

Given the complexity and potential implications of these choices, it’s highly advisable for taxpayers to consult with professional tax advisors. This is especially important to ensure compliance with tax laws and to understand how each option aligns with their broader financial goals and circumstances. Professional advice can provide clarity and guidance, helping taxpayers navigate these choices more effectively.

It’s important to note that tax straddling isn’t suitable for all sales. Gains from debt relief are recognized in the sale year, and a genuine intent to exchange is required for installment sale eligibility.

For further information on tax straddling and other tax deferral strategies, consider contacting 1031 Exchange Place.


1031 Exchange Advisor

Nicholas Dutson has been a dynamic figure in the 1031 exchange industry since 2007. With over two decades of experience in marketing and web development, Nicholas has demonstrated his entrepreneurial spirit by owning an INC 500 company and maintaining a multi-year presence in the INC 5000 list. He is renowned for his dedication and passion for his work. Outside of his professional endeavors, Nicholas is a devoted father to two teenage boys. Together, they share a love for mountain biking and exploring the outdoors on their ATVs every weekend. Nicholas’s commitment to excellence is evident in both his career and personal life.