New York 1031 Exchange & Investment Advisors
1031 Exchange in New York
A 1031 exchange lets New York property investors sell appreciated real estate and reinvest the full proceeds into new property without triggering an immediate tax bill. That matters more here than in almost any other state. New York taxes capital gains as ordinary income with no preferential long-term rate, so a top-bracket seller owes 10.9% to Albany on top of the 20% federal long-term rate and the 3.8% net investment income tax, a combined 34.7%. New York City residents add local income tax of up to 3.876%, pushing the total past 38%. On a $1 million gain, deferral keeps roughly $350,000 to $385,000 working in your next property instead of leaving in a tax payment.
Why New York’s Tax Treatment Makes Deferral So Valuable
New York’s investment landscape runs from Manhattan and Brooklyn multifamily and mixed-use buildings to Long Island industrial, Westchester and Hudson Valley rentals, and net-leased retail across Buffalo, Rochester, Albany, and Syracuse. Whatever you own, the 1031 exchange rules are the same: identify replacement property within 45 days of closing and complete the purchase within 180 days, with proceeds held by a qualified intermediary from the moment of sale. New York’s compressed, competitive markets make those deadlines real; a stalled contract in a co-op board review or a slow title search upstate can turn a routine exchange into a failed 1031 exchange, and the full state and federal bill comes due. Planning the replacement search before you list is the single best protection New York sellers have.
Tenants in Common in New York
Picture a landlord who has spent twenty years running a six-unit building in Queens under New York’s rent stabilization rules, or an upstate owner tired of chasing winter maintenance across a scattered rental portfolio. Selling outright means handing more than a third of the gain to the IRS and Albany. A Tenants in Common structure offers a third path: exchange into a fractional interest in a larger, professionally managed property and keep the full tax deferral.
Trading Management Headaches for Institutional-Grade Ownership
TIC ownership appeals to New York investors for a practical reason: entry-level pricing in the city is steep, and quality single-tenant assets get bid up fast. Pooling with up to 34 co-owners through TIC investments puts Class A office, medical, and multifamily assets within reach at minimums far below what a whole building in the five boroughs commands. Each co-owner holds a deeded interest, which is exactly what makes a TIC 1031 exchange work under IRS guidance. And because TIC interests are direct real estate rather than securities in many structures, there are TIC options for non-accredited investors who would be shut out of most DST offerings.
Delaware Statutory Trust in New York
Consider a Brooklyn brownstone owner closing a $2 million sale with $1.2 million in gain. Between the 20% federal rate, the 3.8% net investment income tax, and New York’s 10.9% top rate, the tax bill approaches $416,000, and a city resident owes more. A Delaware Statutory Trust lets that seller defer the entire amount and step out of active management on the same closing timeline as any other exchange.
Deferring a Six-Figure Tax Bill Without Taking On a New Building
A DST 1031 exchange places sale proceeds into fractional interests in institutional assets, and the DST properties on offer typically include Class A apartment communities, distribution centers, medical office, and net-leased retail across growth markets nationwide. For New Yorkers, that is also a way to diversify out of a single high-tax market while deferring the gain. The trade-offs deserve equal attention: DST interests are illiquid for the life of the trust, investors give up all management control, and offerings are generally limited to accredited investors. Reviewing the Delaware Statutory Trust risks before committing proceeds is essential, because there is no exit before the sponsor sells.
New York Capital Gain Tax Rates
Additional State Capital Gains Tax Information for New York
New York does not offer a reduced rate for long-term capital gains; all gains are taxed as ordinary income on a progressive scale from 4% to 10.9%. New York City residents pay an additional local income tax of up to 3.876%, and Yonkers imposes its own surcharge. Nonresidents selling New York real estate must file Form IT-2663 and prepay estimated tax on the gain at the highest state rate, currently 10.9%, at closing, though property transferred as part of a qualifying 1031 exchange is exempt from that prepayment. To see what a sale would cost you before deciding whether to exchange, run the numbers through a capital gains tax calculator or review current rates and forms at the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance.
Additional State Income Tax Information for New York
New York’s personal income tax runs from 4% on the lowest bracket to 10.9% on income over $25 million, with rates of 9.65% and up applying above roughly $1.1 million. Because rental income and property gains stack on top of wages and other income, a profitable sale can push a New York investor into a higher bracket in the year of sale. That bracket creep is one reason deferral strategies carry outsized value here: spreading or postponing recognition keeps investors out of the top rates that a lump-sum gain would otherwise trigger, and for city residents it avoids compounding the state hit with NYC’s local tax in the same year.
Areas We Serve Within New York
Qualifying Investment Property Across New York State
Nearly any New York real estate held for investment or business use can anchor an exchange: multifamily buildings in the five boroughs, mixed-use storefronts in Brooklyn and Queens, Long Island warehouses and flex industrial, Westchester and Hudson Valley rental homes, farmland and vacant land upstate, and net-leased retail or medical office in Buffalo, Rochester, Albany, and Syracuse. Co-op shares held for investment can qualify as well, a wrinkle nearly unique to New York. Primary residences and property held mainly for resale do not qualify. In tight markets where the right replacement appears before your sale closes, a reverse 1031 exchange lets you acquire first and sell second, a sequencing advantage that matters when a well-priced building in a competitive borough will not wait 180 days for your buyer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does New York State recognize 1031 exchanges?
Yes. New York conforms to federal Section 1031, so gain deferred federally is also deferred for New York State and New York City income tax purposes. There is no separate state-level disallowance, and a properly structured exchange defers the full combined liability.
Do nonresidents selling New York property owe tax at closing?
Generally yes. Nonresident sellers must file Form IT-2663 and prepay estimated income tax on the gain at New York’s highest rate, currently 10.9%, when the deed is recorded. Property transferred as part of a qualifying 1031 exchange is exempt from this prepayment, which makes the exchange paperwork especially valuable for out-of-state owners of New York real estate.
How much capital gains tax does a New York City resident pay without an exchange?
A top-bracket city resident faces the 20% federal long-term rate, the 3.8% net investment income tax, up to 10.9% New York State tax, and up to 3.876% New York City tax, a combined rate approaching 38.6%. On a $500,000 gain that is roughly $193,000 in taxes that a 1031 exchange would defer.
What types of New York investment property qualify for a 1031 exchange?
Any real property held for investment or productive business use qualifies, including apartment buildings, mixed-use and retail buildings, office and industrial space, rental condos, vacant land, farmland, and in many cases investment-held co-op shares. Your primary residence, fix-and-flip inventory, and property held mainly for resale do not qualify.
Can I exchange out of New York into property in another state?
Yes. Section 1031 covers all like-kind real estate within the United States, so you can sell a New York property and buy in Florida, Texas, or any other state while deferring both federal and New York tax on the sale. Keep in mind New York can tax the deferred gain when the replacement property is eventually sold in a taxable transaction, so track your basis carefully across state lines.
Location Details
Suite #304
New York City, NY 10013
Sat-Sun: CLOSED
New York 1031 Exchange Testimonials
I moved a substantial portion of my net worth through this firm and I want to acknowledge what that requires. They handled it with the seriousness it deserved. Every confirmation arrived in writing, every deadline was tracked independently, and I was never asked to take anything on faith. That is what you are actually buying.
My daughter found 1031EX for me. I am eighty-one and I did not want to do this at all, but the property had become too much and my children were right that it was time. I want to say that Nate treated me like a person with a mind of my own, which at my age is not a given. She addressed her questions to me and not to my daughter, who was on the call. She explained things twice when I asked her to, without impatience. The exchange is finished and the income arrives and I understand where it comes from, which was important to me. Thank you to everyone there.
Repeat client. This one had a wrinkle: I changed my identified properties inside the window, which I gather is allowed and is also apparently a headache, and I got a slightly clipped email from Tasha about the revised paperwork. Fair enough, it was my doing. It got processed. I mention it because everything else you'll read about them is frictionless and my experience had one small piece of friction in it that was my fault.