New York 1031 Exchange & Investment Advisors
1031 Exchange in New York
Completing a 1031 exchange matters more in New York than almost anywhere else in the country. The state taxes capital gains as ordinary income at rates up to 10.9%, and when you stack that on top of the 20% federal long-term rate and the 3.8% net investment income tax, a New York seller can face a combined bill of 34.7% before New York City’s own income tax even enters the picture. Add federal depreciation recapture at 25% on years of accumulated deductions, and an outright sale of a long-held building can hand more than a third of your gain to tax authorities. An exchange defers all of it, keeping the full sale proceeds working in your next property.
From Rent-Stabilized Multifamily to Upstate Industrial: Where New York Exchanges Happen
New York’s exchange activity reflects its unusual market pressures. Since the 2019 rent law changes capped what owners of rent-stabilized buildings can recover through renovations, many longtime multifamily landlords in Brooklyn, Queens, and the Bronx have chosen to exchange into free-market assets, net lease retail on Long Island and in Westchester, or industrial and medical office properties in Buffalo, Rochester, Albany, and Syracuse. Whatever the strategy, the 1031 exchange rules are unforgiving: you have 45 days from closing to identify replacement property and 180 days to complete the purchase, and a qualified intermediary must hold your proceeds from the moment your relinquished property closes. Touch the funds yourself, even briefly, and the exchange fails.
Tenants in Common in New York
Picture a Queens landlord who just sold a six-unit walk-up for $2.8 million after three decades of midnight boiler calls and Housing Court appearances. She wants to stay invested in real estate and defer her taxes, but she is done being a landlord. Co-ownership through Tenants in Common lets her place her exchange proceeds into a fractional interest in a professionally managed office, retail, or apartment property, often alongside a handful of other investors in the same position. Before committing, it helps to run the numbers and compare the two outcomes side by side: a taxable sale that surrenders a third of the gain versus an exchange into passive co-ownership that keeps everything invested.
Institutional-Grade Buildings Without an Institutional-Sized Check
The math of New York real estate makes fractional ownership especially useful here. A quality Manhattan or Brooklyn asset routinely trades above $10 million, far past what most individual exchangers can buy alone, but TIC investments typically accept commitments in the hundreds of thousands, which means a seller of a single outer-borough building can access the kind of property that usually belongs to REITs and pension funds. Because each co-owner holds a deeded interest, the IRS treats it as like-kind real estate, and the structure permits up to 35 co-owners per property. Our team maintains relationships with sponsors across the country and can match your timeline and proceeds against available TIC properties well before your 45-day identification deadline arrives.
Delaware Statutory Trust in New York
Consider an investor who bought a Park Slope brownstone rental in the 1990s for $600,000 and can sell it today for $3.6 million. She is in her seventies, her children live out of state, and she has no interest in a new mortgage or a new tenant roster. Exchanging into a Delaware Statutory Trust lets her defer the entire gain while converting an active management burden into fractional interests in institutional assets such as distribution centers, Class A apartments, or medical office portfolios. A DST 1031 exchange also solves the deadline problem: because trust interests are pre-packaged and already financed, they can often close in days rather than months, making Delaware Statutory Trust investments a reliable backup identification even for investors pursuing a conventional purchase.
What Deferral Is Worth on a Seven-Figure New York Gain
Run the numbers on that $3 million gain. Federal long-term capital gains at 20% takes $600,000, the net investment income tax adds $114,000, New York State at 9.65% claims roughly $290,000, and a New York City resident owes nearly $116,000 more, a combined bill approaching $1.1 million once depreciation recapture is included. A DST defers every dollar of it. That said, these are long-term, illiquid positions with no ready resale market, they are generally available only to accredited investors, and investors give up control over management and sale timing. Understanding Delaware Statutory Trust risks before you identify one is essential, and our advisors will walk you through sponsor track records, debt terms, and exit assumptions before you commit.
New York Capital Gain Tax Rates
Additional State Capital Gains Tax Information for New York
New York has no preferential rate for long-term capital gains; profits from a property sale are taxed as ordinary income under the state’s progressive brackets, which run from 4% to 10.9%. A large one-time gain can push a seller several brackets higher in the year of sale, and New York City residents pay an additional local income tax of up to 3.876% on the same gain. Nonresidents selling New York real estate face an estimated tax prepayment at closing under Form IT-2663, calculated at the state’s top rate, although a properly structured 1031 exchange qualifies for an exemption from that prepayment. To see what a sale of your property would actually cost, our capital gains tax calculator breaks down the federal, state, and local layers, and current rates and forms are published by the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance.
Additional State Income Tax Information for New York
New York’s income tax structure shapes nearly every real estate decision investors make here. The state’s nine brackets top out at 10.9%, among the highest in the nation, and rental income, gains, and recaptured depreciation all flow through them. New York City layers its own tax on residents, while Yonkers imposes a resident surcharge as well. For nonresident owners, New York sources both rental income and sale gains from New York property to the state, so moving to Florida before a sale does not remove the New York tax on a New York building. These stacked obligations are why deferral strategies carry more value per dollar of gain in New York than in nearly any other market: every year of deferral keeps money compounding that would otherwise be gone at closing.
Areas We Serve Within New York
New York Property That Qualifies for a 1031 Exchange
Nearly any New York real estate held for investment or business use qualifies: multifamily buildings in the five boroughs, mixed-use storefronts in Westchester, net lease retail on Long Island, warehouses along the Thruway corridor, farmland in the Hudson Valley, office condominiums in Manhattan, and even a Catskills vacation rental that meets the IRS’s rental-use tests. Like-kind is broader than most investors assume, so a Bronx apartment building can become a Charlotte distribution center or a portfolio of DST interests spread across a dozen states. Timing problems have solutions too: if the ideal replacement property surfaces before your current building sells, a reverse 1031 exchange lets you acquire first and sell second. What does not qualify is your primary residence, property held mainly for resale such as a fix-and-flip, and, in most cases, co-op shares held for personal use rather than investment.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does New York recognize 1031 exchange tax deferral?
Yes. New York conforms to Internal Revenue Code Section 1031, so a properly executed exchange defers both your federal capital gains tax and your New York State income tax on the gain, along with New York City tax for city residents. No separate state election is required; the deferral flows through from your federal return.
How does New York's IT-2663 withholding affect nonresident sellers doing an exchange?
Nonresidents selling New York real estate normally must prepay estimated income tax on the gain at closing using Form IT-2663, computed at the state’s top rate of 10.9%. If the sale is part of a 1031 exchange in which the entire gain is deferred, the seller can claim an exemption on the form and skip the prepayment. If the exchange is only partial, estimated tax is due on the recognized portion.
What types of New York investment property qualify for a 1031 exchange?
Apartment buildings, brownstone rentals, mixed-use and retail properties, office space, industrial buildings, farmland, and vacation rentals that satisfy investment-use requirements all qualify. The property must be held for investment or business use, not as a primary residence or for quick resale. Investment real estate anywhere in the United States is like-kind to New York property, so you can exchange into or out of the state freely.
If I exchange my New York property for one in another state, does New York ever tax the deferred gain?
Potentially, yes. Gain from New York real estate is New York-source income, so if you later sell the out-of-state replacement property in a taxable sale, the portion of gain that originated in New York can still be subject to New York tax, even if you are no longer a resident. Unlike California, New York does not require an annual information filing to track the deferred gain, but the sourcing rule itself does not disappear. Many investors address this by continuing to exchange or by holding until death, when heirs receive a stepped-up basis.
Does a 1031 exchange defer New York's real estate transfer taxes?
No. The state real estate transfer tax, the additional mansion tax on qualifying residential sales, and New York City’s Real Property Transfer Tax are all transaction taxes on the conveyance itself, and they are due at closing whether or not you complete an exchange. A 1031 exchange defers income taxes on your gain: federal capital gains tax, the net investment income tax, depreciation recapture, and state and city income taxes.
Location Details
Suite #304
New York City, NY 10013
Sat-Sun: CLOSED
New York 1031 Exchange Testimonials
Their understanding of tenants in common properties was impressive. I had a great experience with 1031 Exchange Place during my 1031 exchange. Anyone considering a 1031 exchange should use their services. The entire process was smooth and stress-free. Nate's assistance in locating a suitable replacement property was invaluable.
They clearly have a lot of expertise in tenants in common properties. Nate's expertise was crucial in finding the perfect replacement property. My experience with 1031 Exchange Place for my 1031 exchange was truly remarkable. Everything went smoothly and without any stress. I had a great experience with 1031 Exchange Place during my 1031 exchange.
My experience with 1031 Exchange Place for my 1031 exchange was truly remarkable. I had a great experience with 1031 Exchange Place during my 1031 exchange. Anyone considering a 1031 exchange should use their services. Their services for a 1031 exchange come highly recommended. Nate's guidance made finding a replacement property a breeze.